Page 1:Power Supply Troubleshooting
Page 2:Background Story On Today's Patient
Page 3:Preliminary Testing: The 5VSB Rail
Page 4:Preliminary Testing: PS_ON# Behavior
Page 5:Words Of Caution
Page 6:PCB Analysis
Page 7:The Test Plan
Page 8:Setup And Safety
Page 9:5VSB Capacitor Replacement
Page 10:Auxiliary Output Results
Page 11:Auxiliary Output Capacitor Replacement
Page 12:PWM Bypass Capacitor Results
Page 13:Capacitor Postmortem
Page 14:Do We Have A Definitive Fix?
Preliminary Testing: PS_ON# Behavior
We already know that the supply has horrible deviations on the 5VSB output, so the next thing to look at would be correlation between the abnormal 5VSB output and turn-on failure.
This first slide shows what happens at turn-on with the old 5VSB caps and no loading on 5VSB. The 5VSB output looks like junk throughout, but its DC value remains close to 5V and the main outputs look perfectly fine. While the overshoots aren't pretty, they are still within the 10% turn-on tolerance. In the remaining four slides, I added a 1200µF cap connected to the 5VSB pin on the ATX connector.
With the addition of that cap and no further changes, things go down the drain. Although the high-frequency content on the 5VSB line was greatly reduced, I now appear to have a problem with the 5VSB flyback operating irregularly, pulsing at about 500Hz. After 70ms though, the unit decides to shut down.
This time, I added the shunt voltage regulator from the previous page on the 5VSB output and adjusted the set-point voltage until I got 100mA through it before signaling PS_ON#. Now the flyback is pulsing at 600Hz and the main outputs are looking much livelier. They still shut down near the 82ms mark and do not look like anything you would want near your components.
Dialing the load up to 200mA produces these traces and the first quasi-successful power-up: the 5VSB flyback is operating at 700Hz, the main rails manage to reach their respective nominal voltages and stay on. However, they do miserably fail the “smooth ramp” and 20ms maximum rise time requirements from Intel's 2013 PSU design guide. Results are also highly dependent on warm-up and cool-down times between runs.
Stepping things up to 250mA starts looking good: the 5VSB flyback still has some minor hiccups just before main outputs come to life but it is now operating steady through the whole ramp, the main output ramps are much smoother and take just over 10ms.
At 300mA of dummy loading, the main output ramps look as good as they are going to get.
What do all of these waveforms have in common? They all show a dip on the 5VSB output just before the main outputs start coming to life, and during that dip, the 5VSB output behaves itself better than usual.
What preliminary conclusions can we draw from these observations? The strong correlation between how steady the 5VSB flyback is and how smooth the main output ramps are tells me the main switcher must either be bootstrapping from or entirely powered by an auxiliary output on the 5VSB flyback, and irregular flyback operation is preventing the main switcher from receiving steady enough power to operate normally. If I am correct about it, I should be able to loosen this dependency by putting a larger capacitor in the controller's power supply. If the controller's bootstrap happens to be tied into the 5VSB feedback circuit on the primary side, this could also explain the non-loaded voltage increase to 6V with either fresh caps or external caps. The main converter being powered by an auxiliary winding on the 5VSB supply would also explain the dip just before outputs start ramping up.
- Power Supply Troubleshooting
- Background Story On Today's Patient
- Preliminary Testing: The 5VSB Rail
- Preliminary Testing: PS_ON# Behavior
- Words Of Caution
- PCB Analysis
- The Test Plan
- Setup And Safety
- 5VSB Capacitor Replacement
- Auxiliary Output Results
- Auxiliary Output Capacitor Replacement
- PWM Bypass Capacitor Results
- Capacitor Postmortem
- Do We Have A Definitive Fix?