Page 1:Bring On The Cheap 1080p IPS Panels!
Page 2:Measurement And Calibration Methodology
Page 3:Results: Stock Brightness And Contrast
Page 4:Results: Calibrated Brightness And Contrast
Page 5:Results: Gamma And ANSI Contrast Ratio
Page 6:Results: Grayscale Tracking
Page 7:Results: Color Gamut And Performance
Page 8:Results: Viewing Angle And Uniformity
Page 9:Results: Pixel Response And Input Lag
Page 10:Sharp New Screens For 2013
Results: Grayscale Tracking
As with gamma, it’s important for a display to render white at the correct color temperature at all levels of brightness. AOC’s stock measurements are displayed in the graph below:
This is a slightly cool result, but if you check out the Delta E chart, the second one down, you see that the error is small. The green line (3) is where color error becomes visible to the naked eye. Only the 100 percent level shows any serious grayscale error, which is pretty good for out-of-box performance.
After performing a calibration with CalMAN 5.0 and the i1Pro spectrophotometer, we measured the following result:
Aside from 20 and 30 percent, this monitor displays essentially perfect grayscale tracking.
The ViewSonic screen's out-of-box color temperature preset, referred to as Native, looks quite green in hue. The image appears much more natural under the User Color preset with the RGB sliders at their default values.
All levels above 30 percent have a visible error, which rises to the 100 percent level.
After calibration, the tracking is excellent with only slight changes to the RGB controls. There is no visible error at any brightness level.
With grayscale tracking this good, you can be sure that all shades of gray will appear neutral and un-tinted. Both monitors are extremely accurate in this regard.
AOC Versus ViewSonic
Grayscale error, expressed here as a Delta E average, shows how much a monitor deviates from the correct color temperature of 6500 Kelvin over its entire brightness range. Anything over a value of three is considered visible to the naked eye.
Even without calibration, the error for both monitors is barely visible. This is simply excellent performance.
The error drops under two after calibration with CalMAN and i1Pro, and as you can see in the graphs earlier on the page, the error is low at all brightness levels.
Comparing the AOC and ViewSonic reveals little difference in stock or calibrated performance. Both are extremely accurate monitors that will look great for both video and gaming content, with or without instrumented calibration.
- Bring On The Cheap 1080p IPS Panels!
- Measurement And Calibration Methodology
- Results: Stock Brightness And Contrast
- Results: Calibrated Brightness And Contrast
- Results: Gamma And ANSI Contrast Ratio
- Results: Grayscale Tracking
- Results: Color Gamut And Performance
- Results: Viewing Angle And Uniformity
- Results: Pixel Response And Input Lag
- Sharp New Screens For 2013