Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No

System Builder Marathon: The $5,000 Extreme PC

by

System Builder Marathon, February 2009: The Articles

Here are links to each of the four articles in this month’s System Builder Marathon (we’ll update them as each story is published).

  • Day 1: The $625 Gaming PC
  • Day 2: The $1,250 Mid-Range PC
  • Day 3: The $5,000 Enthusiast PC
  • Day 4: Performance and Value Dissected

Introduction

The only people who can truly understand the logic behind spending a month’s pay on a computer are those who have actually used such a system. Everyone else seems to think such behavior is silly. Up-and-coming enthusiasts aspire to acquire this level of performance and capability in a gaming machine without spending as much, while ordinary performance fanatics pretend not to care. Then again, stereotypes concerning “overcompensation” were invented out of envy and are projected by those who are afraid to admit that they too would love to own such a machine.

Last month we scaled back our highest-end system to $2,500, opening the configuration to a far larger market that typifies the budget of high-end do-it-yourselfers. But while the $2,500 market is dear to us and certainly worth revisiting, a number of readers wanted to see what kind of dream system we could build if given twice the budget. Rather than choose the entire configuration ourselves, we used your recommendations as guidelines to narrow our choice of parts.

$5,000 Extreme Performance System Components
Component

Model

Price (USD)

CPU

Intel Core i7 Extreme 965

$1,010

CPU Cooler

Cooler Master Aquagate Max

$230

Radiator Upgrade

Swiftech MCR320-QP Quiet Power

$50

Fan Upgrade

3x Scythe S-FLEX SFF21F 120 mm 1,600 RPM

$47

Water Block Upgrade

Swiftech Apogee GTZ with LGA-1366 Bracket

$75

Motherboard

Asus Rampage II Extreme

$400

RAM

Mushkin 998679 DDR3-1600 6.0 GB Kit

$205

Graphics

2x MSI N295GTX-M2D1792 GeForce GTX 295

$1,000

System Hard Drives

2x Intel X25-M 80GB SATA Solid State Disk

$800

2.5" Hard Drive Adapter

SYBA Mobile Rack for 2.5" SATA (2 drives)

$36

Storage Hard Drive

Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 1.5 TB SATA 3.0 GB/s

$130

Sound

Asus SupremeFX X-Fi Audio Riser Card

0

Network

Integrated Gigabit Networking

0

Case

Cooler Master Cosmos-S RC-1100

$200

Power

Cooler Master Real Power Pro RS-850-EMBA

$180

Optical

LG Blu-ray Burner/HD DVD-ROM GGW-H20LK

$200

Total Price

$4,563


Several readers requested a switch to solid-state disk (SSD) drives, so we included them. Other suggestions, such as a hardware RAID controller card, were swiftly dismissed after the drives we chose consumed the budget. The budget eased when prices dropped after our order was placed, but that’s par for the course in the component market. We even bought a sound card, only to have it priced out of our configuration before we started testing, with later price drops occurring only after the tests were complete.

We have a few more surprises to discuss, so feel free to follow along as we detail the assembly, tuning, and testing of today’s super-high-end system.

Share:
27
Comments
Read more
X
Submit

Comments
Read the comments on the forums
waxdart 12/02/2009 11:01
Hide
-0+

I can't help but think - what do you get for $10,000 :)
Thanks for these keep it going. I'll not be spending that about anytime soon.

LePhuronn 12/02/2009 11:13
Hide
-0+

@waxdart:

i7 Skulltrail (if the rumours are true) with 24GB of RAM. Hell, each i7 CPU can deal with 24GB, so would QPI allow for 24GB EACH?

A pair of 965s overclocked to 5GHz+ each with 48GB RAM...my Christ! Hell, bring on the Vapochill units and see if we can go to 7GHz! Overclocked GTX295s, SSDs in a RAID 0 on a dedicated controller card...

THAT is what $10,000 will allow :-D

LePhuronn 12/02/2009 11:15
Hide
-0+

In all seriousness though, although it's great to spec up these stupid systems, what is really interesting is the overall value of them. Tom's price-performance ratio is always a very good guide as to exactly what you benefit from with these insane builds (other than a techno-boner the size of Mount Fuji and extreme bragging rights).

LePhuronn 12/02/2009 11:34
Hide
-0+

And now that I've finished the article, I must say I'm a little disappointed that the 965 couldn't even get up to 5Ghz on liquid, but as pointed out who knows what quality that Extreme edition was inside - the 920 could've been a fluke or the 965 could've been unfortunate.

Still, it is heartwarming to know that I'm not missing out clocking my 920 to 4GHz - who needs 6.4GT/s anyway?

Anonymous 12/02/2009 13:31
Hide
-0+

would 2x80Gb RAID 0 SSDs be much faster then a single 160Gb SSD?

david__t 12/02/2009 14:12
Hide
-0+

RAID 0 is the hard drive equivalent of dual channel memory where both drives are accessed at the same time for each file request - thereby giving you an instant theoretical doubling of bandwidth. In the real world you don't get exactly double the normal speed but you do get a significant increase over a single drive.

s3k3r 12/02/2009 14:57
Hide
-0+

wow nice.... But wtf???!! graphics drivers for quad sli is somekinda weird at 2560x1600

Anonymous 12/02/2009 16:10
Hide
-0+

@david__t:
I thuoght dual channel memory works very different than a RAID0 because you can read only one memory address at the same time. With dual channel you can just use the "gaps" between 2 read requests while in RAID0 you can address both drives simultaneously.

avatar_raq 12/02/2009 17:29
Hide
-0+

Thanks for building my dream PC!! I wished you build such a system about 2 months ago and you didn't disappoint me.
I have a few notes.
1)Thomas, could you please just tell us the brand of the failed PSU? A failing high-end high wattage unit is a disaster!
2)I did't see any real world performance gain from the dual SSDs!! Comparing to the last months build, you attributed the performance gains in synthetics, encoding and productivity tests to the added ram. Am I wrong? Are SSDs worth the price? From what I understand the storage drive usually have little impact on the overall performance.
3)For 5000$ I expected you to cool the whole system with water..There are water cooler ready ram kits from OCZ, GTX 295 water blocks offered by many brands (suprisingly more than the older socket 1366 blocks!), north bridge and even HDD water blocks!!! Perhaps if you drop the SSDs you could have afforded them within the price range, and the GPU and video RAM could have reached higher clocks. After all, expensive systems as this one are all about superiority and uniquity!!
Again thanks for the great work, you've put a lot of effort into this one and we appreciate it.

LePhuronn 12/02/2009 22:59
Hide
-0+

@avatar_raq:

In this specific case I doubt they'd get any higher OCs - as already stated you are sometimes at the mercy of the quality of the production, and it looks like this 965 topped at the 4.2GHz - I don't thinking watercooling Northbridges or whatever to push the chipset is going to get much further here.

starmate 14/02/2009 12:27
Hide
-1+

For UK:
Component
Model
Price (GBP)

CPU
Intel Core i7 Extreme 965
£825

CPU Cooler
Cooler Master Aquagate Max
£165

Radiator Upgrade
Swiftech MCR320-QP Quiet Power
£35

Fan Upgrade
3x Scythe S-FLEX SFF21F 120 mm 1,600 RPM
£45

Water Block Upgrade
Swiftech Apogee GTZ with LGA-1366 Bracket
£62

Motherboard
Asus Rampage II Extreme
£290

RAM
Mushkin 998679 DDR3-1600 6.0 GB Kit
£195

Graphics
2x MSI N295GTX-M2D1792 GeForce GTX 295
£725

System Hard Drives
2x Intel X25-M 80GB SATA Solid State Disk
£695

2.5" Hard Drive Adapter
SYBA Mobile Rack for 2.5" SATA (2 drives)
£25

Storage Hard Drive
Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 1.5 TB SATA 3.0 GB/s
£110

Sound
Asus SupremeFX X-Fi Audio Riser Card
0

Network
Integrated Gigabit Networking
0

Case
Cooler Master Cosmos-S RC-1100
£150

Power
Cooler Master Real Power Pro RS-850-EMBA
£130

Optical
LG Blu-ray Burner/HD DVD-ROM GGW-H20LK
£145

Total Price

£3,597

Prices taken from various uk big-sellers as of febuary 14.

3dguy 16/02/2009 07:12
Hide
-0+

My new workstation at work is still more expensive
Xeon X5482 x2, 32gig ram, Quatro FX 5600 etc
Renders things a bit quicker than my older machine
Cost a bit over $13k =)

2shea 17/02/2009 11:47
Hide
-0+

owww I'm getting a boner already... oh no wait sorry I forgot that my girfriend is here... seriously, bragging with your workstation is so sad...

2shea 17/02/2009 11:47
Hide
-0+

owww I'm getting a boner already... oh no wait sorry I forgot that my girfriend is here... seriously, bragging with your workstation is so sad...

OMGiTzzFATAL 17/02/2009 19:59
Hide
-0+

You guys have a cool job :D

But seriously what game or app uses that much power?
I'll stick with my E8400@4.7ghz and my HD4870's in Crossfire.

LePhuronn 18/02/2009 12:15
Hide
-0+

@OMGiTzzFATAL:

You've obviously had no experience with media production then - that sort of rig is fairly entry-level these days for video editing, motion graphics and 3D modelling. And to be honest, for some of the high-level stuff that rig is pretty under-powered.

As a gaming rig, it's more power than you're ever going to need (and the GPUs will be obsolete before games ever start making use of multiple cores) but for media, I'd up to at least 12GB of RAM and go dual CPU is I could (hence i7 Skulltrail) and SLI some Quadro CXs instead.

Mmmmmmmmmmmm

OMGiTzzFATAL 18/02/2009 09:54
Hide
-0+

Lol Lephuronn, I'm not saying my comp is the dogs bits, All im saying is i personally wouldn't spend that kind of money on a PC.

I don't understand your point regarding my multi GPU setup. Crossfire scales fairly well nowadays, Even fairly old games like cod4 has multi GPU support.

Some people work hard for their setup, I think you should learn to have some respect.

LePhuronn 18/02/2009 11:09
Hide
-0+

@OMGiTzzFATAL:

I'm not sure where you think I'm being disrespectful in stating above that this system has more power than any "normal" user will ever utilise any time soon (except for Crysis, but that glorified tech demo always throws spec comparisons out of kilter).

My point regarding multi-GPUs is quite simply as I stated - GPUs will become obsolete with games before the CPU ever will be, hence the focus on GPUs on gaming rigs not CPUs. Why else is a Core 2 Duo the prime choice for gaming systems when Core 2 Quads can clock just as fast but have twice the number of cores?

You asked the question "but seriously what game or app uses that much power?". I answered. I do things at work on a daily basis that would eat through the $5,000 spec and still have room for more.

I cannot see how me saying I know something that DOES use that much power is somehow disrespectful, and quite frankly I'm insulted at the insinuation.

OMGiTzzFATAL 18/02/2009 11:57
Hide
-0+

To answer your question, A E8400 can easily overclock to 4ghz, And in my case 4.5ghz and 4.7ghz for benching. Where as a Q6600 (roughly the same amount of money) can only do 3.2-3.4, I know of two people that can only get to 3ghz without having heat issues.

An considering most games don't use 4cores, a higher clocked C2D will be the better option as far as games are concerned.

Sorry if i have insulted you, I was only trying to say that not everyone has a huge amount of money to spend on a pc.

LePhuronn 18/02/2009 20:23
Hide
-0+

@OMGiTzzFATAL:

I agree entirely with what you said (I was making a statement, not asking a question) and that's my point - games are driven by GPUs predominantly because they don't take advantage of more than 2 cores. So, to return to what I said previously, if you're a gamer then the $5,000 system is more power than you're going to need.

However, to respond to your question: media production, motion graphics, 3D modelling, etc. will utilise all that power and then some.

Never once did I say anything about people or realistic budgets - I was talking purely about the hardware - and I really don't see where you think I could've done. No need to apologise though it's just a kneejerk reaction I seem to get posting here - I get frustrated that everytime I say something on these comments there's always somebody who misinterprets what I say.

Such is thar interwebz.


Best offers

Newsletters


OK