Audio Comparison: Putting MP3, WMA, And AAC Under A Microscope, Continued
Audio Comparison: Putting MP3, WMA, And AAC Under A Microscope, Continued

The MP3-encoded version (in red) of the track had some interesting properties. It seems that the compression algorithm had cut off all sound above 15.8 kHz. This technique is useful in shrinking the resulting MP3 in size and banks on the fact that very little of the sound resides in 15.8 kHz+ range. The leveling of the audio at low, mid, and high frequency appeared to be flat.

The AAC file (in blue) as shown by the graph, held pretty much true to the original wav file in terms of level at low, mid, and high frequencies. The only major deviation from the WAV file was in the 20 kHz+ range, which we cannot hear anyway.

The results for the WMA file in the frequency analysis were quite good. Like the ACC file, the leveling of the WMA seemed to have a high fidelity to the original track. It had, however, a curiously low frequency cutoff at around 14 kHz, well within the range of human hearing.
The frequency analysis alone cannot tell which file format is better or worse. What is becoming obvious, though, is how the MP3 file stands out from the other two files in terms of lower level fidelity. These signs definitely show that MP3 is aging.
- Previous page Audio Comparison: Putting MP3, WMA,...
- Next page How Does It All Sound?
- How To Add Front - Mounted Ports To Your Case
- Netgear ProSafe VPN Firewall Review
- Second Hand Smoke - Stop Smothering AMD!
- The Third THG Video: Silent and Ice Cold
- Integrated Graphics: Take on Discrete Dinosaurs?
- MP3 Hard Drive To Portability
- Attack Out Of The Blind Spot: Matrox Parhelia-512
- VPU Technology Preview: The Wildcat VP Series From 3Dlabs
- How We Test 802.11a Wireless Products
- How We Test 802.11b and 11g Wireless LAN Products [Older Reviews]
- Comparison of Nokia N-series phones: N95, N93, N73
- The Year in Review: The Good, The Bad and the Ugly
- To share my experience: convert iTunes videos to MPEG,WMV...
- TiVo Anywhere
- How long before a MOD chip comes out for the Replay??
- TIVO capabilities
- 4DTV with a small dish for 1 satellite?
- LD quality differences
- Axim X51 due Sept 19th, 2005
- inspiron 9300?
-
wireless music
-
music programs
-
olympus voice music DM1 WOW technical
-
mobile
-
t mobile
-
mobile workstation
-
Mobile graphics
-
sata mobile
-
mobile cpu
-
mobile broadband
-
mobile gpu
-
mobile gpu charts
-
mobile graphics chart
-
mobile athlon x2 ql60
-
best mobile graphics
-
turn your mobile
-
ATI Mobile RADEON 9800
-
Mobile Intel GMA 4500MHD