Categories:

MacBook Air Comparisons

06:50 - Wednesday 30 April 2008 by Pierre Dandumont
Source: Tom's Hardware – Keywords: lenovo, x300, macbook
Categories: Mobile

MacBook Air Comparisons

Ad

Booting up

Lenovo X300

Windows Vista boots two times slower than the Mac OS X does. The two systems with the different operating systems are not directly comparable, of course, but the Mac OS X is just faster.

Photoshop CS3

Lenovo X300

Lenovo X300

The time it takes for Photoshop CS3 to load up is comparable on both machines, even if the Windows version is faster. However, the Mac OS X version loads image files faster.

Autonomy

We used Microsoft Office and compressed a large file for these tests.

Lenovo X300

The launching and initialization of Microsoft Word (2008 on Mac, 2007 on Windows) was interesting to compare, since the Windows version launched almost immediately, while the Mac version was very slow.

File Decompression

lenovo x300

For the last test, we tried to decompress one archive (rar) that contained some big files (about 500 MB) and a lot of smaller files (less than 1 MB). With this precise test, we wanted to see any drawbacks the X300’s SSD hard drive might have for writing small files. However, the X300’s SSD hard drive is much faster than the MacBook Air’s drive, as the results show.

Stand-By

With a processor that consumes relatively little power and an LED screen, the X300 should have good stand-by time. Indeed, the X300 lasted about six hours and 30 minutes on a charge with our test unit’s six-cell battery. And with another battery in place of the optical drive, Lenovo says the X300’s battery life can last up to 10 hours in stand-by mode on a charge.

DVD Playback

We were able to watch a DVD with the screen resolution set to a minimum for 2 hours and 14 minutes on a charge. This was long enough to watch most of the movie but was still a little short. Also, the screen isn’t well adapted for watching movies.

With 3G

Our other test consisted of using the X300 with a 3G connection. By deactivating Wi-Fi and Bluetooth and setting the screen to 7 bars (from 15), we were able to work for 4 hours and 25 minutes. By reducing the luminosity and deactivating the 3G connection, the battery life should be able to last up to six hours.

Lenovo X300 Lenovo X300

Lenovo suggests replacing the optical drive with a three-cell battery to improve stand-by time. However, doing so requires a screwdriver and is a little inconvenient


Talkback
MagicWok 01/05/2008 06:15
Hide
-1+
MagicWok
"3D performance lags somewhat"

That is a really stupid comment for a laptop that is obviously not meant for anything 3D. Even if the comment was in jest, you could have said something about how damn ugly it is or the screen luminosity which you kept harping on about through the review.
gow87 01/05/2008 07:53
Hide
-0+
gow87
i would still take the mac.. and for one good reason, OSX

this comes to you from a vista laptop that refuses to recognise a mouse and upon startup takes about 2-3 minutes of constant harddrive access to load up
AlexisV 05/05/2008 02:08
Hide
-0+
AlexisV
Why would anyone want to own a Lenovo Thinkpad of any description? They look and feel like 'My First Laptop', are as ugly as sin and as aesthetic as an anvil.
AlexisV 05/05/2008 02:08
Hide
-0+
AlexisV
Why would anyone want to own a Lenovo Thinkpad of any description? They look and feel like 'My First Laptop', are as ugly as sin and as aesthetic as an anvil.
darthpoik 06/05/2008 05:52
Hide
-0+
darthpoik
Macs suck

Note You are going to post a comment as anonymous.



Google Ads