Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > Homebuilt > [Solved] Recommended Builds by Usage

[Solved] Recommended Builds by Usage - Page 3

Forum Homebuilt Systems : Homebuilt [Solved] Recommended Builds by Usage [Solved] Recommended Builds by Usage

Best answer from 4Ryan6.

Word :    Username :           
 

Last message on previous page:
Hi guys

This is my first time building a computer, and I am very interested in sticking with this guide using the i5 750 "gamer" config. But since I have a more flexible budget, I`d like to know what do you think of opting instead for the i7 860 and a radeon HD5870 using the same components listed for the i5... Would it have a significant increase of performance in games?

I've also looked at the i7 920 enthusiast option, but did not consider it because i have no interest (or know-how) to overclock my cpu, nor do I pretend doing cross-fire.

thank you.

Thiago

Reply to thiagobc
Register or log in to remove.

The 5870 would definitely increase performance if you have a good sized monitor. The i7 860 could for some games and could not for others.

Reply to dndhatcher

Thanks for reviewing my thread and getting ideas... That is what it is for. :)

I do think an upgrade to the i7 860 & ATI 5870 is worth it & will work just fine with my other components listed. If you are getting from Newegg, I would check for combos to save yourself some additional money.

If you want more feedback, I would start your own thread with the parts you are looking to buy & others will provide feedback.
Good luck!!

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

Some recommendations on the AMD Gamer build to save money or have better specs:

Case - Antec 900 (free shipping HELPS a lot)
RAM - Mushkin DDR3 1600mhz 7-7-7-20 (faster timings, less $$)
HSF - Mugen Scythe 2 (more silent for same airflow)
Mobo - MSI 790FX-GD70 (best AM3 board, less $$, performs better than Asus Crosshair III Formula and M4A79T)

Also, I would recommend the Razer Lachesis mouse for Gamer budgets, but it really isn't for everyone, although great for lefties.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by kokin on 10-25-2009 at 02:34:51 PM
Reply to kokin

OP, could you review my CPU Buyer's Guide for linkage?

------------------------------ http://piro.pirocast.net/badge/none/fah01/800/96/5/5/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/0/255/255/255/406896.png
Reply to smithereen

smithereen wrote :

OP, could you review my CPU Buyer's Guide for linkage?


Great link smithereen... I have added a link to my thread.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34


I will look at the RAM and HAF on my next review for updates. They look like good deals. I have a bad taste (experience) with MSI (MOBO died and killed my Q6600), so I can't recommend them on a personal level. :) Antec 900 is a good case so I might look at it for both the AM3 & i5 Gamer builds.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

hey tecmo i have some suggestions on the htpc build ,do you really need sucha powerful mobo for a htpc? maybe something basic but not skimpy like a 770 or 785

 

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813131603

 

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813131397

 

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813131398

 

with the new athlon x3's out i would think something like the athlon 425 x3 would extend the longivity of a good htpc in a multicore age

 

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6819103726

 

possibly a new budget mouse has bout all the features the enthusiast razer has take a look

 

http://www.directron.com/sgm6000kllw1gp.html?pgrab=1 dunno when newegg will list it


Message edited by obsidian86 on 10-28-2009 at 06:54:38 PM
Reply to obsidian86
Best answer

This topic has been sticky in top of the forum by 4ryan6

------------------------------ Cooling Fan Roundup
Thermal Compound Roundup

 

Reply to 4Ryan6

Hurray! :bounce: Finally! :bounce:
Congratz Techmo.

Reply to dndhatcher

tecmo34 wrote :

The person that gets my vote for best answer will go to the Moderator who makes this thread a sticky!!! :kaola: [:thegreatgrapeape]


4Ryan6 wrote :

This topic has been sticky in top of the forum by 4ryan6

 

Well done tecmo!


Message edited by jbakerlent on 11-04-2009 at 12:26:51 AM
Reply to jbakerlent

congrats tec


Message edited by obsidian86 on 11-03-2009 at 06:14:23 PM
Reply to obsidian86

Hey tecmo34

I am building a build similar to your i5 budget build. I just think you should upgrade the psu to the 650W antec earthwatts, its $10 dollars more and would allow for the GPU HD 5770 to be CF later down the line instead of a person having to buy another PSU for more performance. Thats the route I am taking at least. I think it warrants the $10 dollar change on your build. But great stuff :)

Reply to Ironman01

I don't spend nearly the amount of time I did on this site before, and was stoked to see you stuck with this and got the sticky. CONGRATS

------------------------------ Use this format when ASKING FOR BUILD ADVISE

 

Reply to skora

skora wrote :

I don't spend nearly the amount of time I did on this site before, and was stoked to see you stuck with this and got the sticky. CONGRATS


Thank You and glad to see you back around here.

Your thread still lives on with references in jbakerlent's, Proixmon's and my stickies! If you ever get back on THG more, you have outlets to update your original index threads.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

tecmo34 wrote :

Thank You and glad to see you back around here.

Your thread still lives on with references in jbakerlent's, Proixmon's and my stickies! If you ever get back on THG more, you have outlets to update your original index threads.


I just fell out of my chair. :o I had no idea that was still being used as reference. That's the kind of inspiration I need to dig back in and update/add to it. I saw the work you were doing and figured the overlapping nature didn't justify both threads running and didn't have the time to keep it updated. Maybe I'll just stick to the odd builds or around a specific sale or something.

------------------------------ Use this format when ASKING FOR BUILD ADVISE

 

Reply to skora

Great guide! For the higher end speakers, you might want to add studio monitors.

M-Audio BX5a's are good for computer speakers. So are KRK RP5's.

http://www.m-audio.com/products/en [...] eluxe.html

and...

http://www.krksys.com/product_rokit.php

Reply to Zinosys

Minor Updates and add the build I'm putting together this weekend for my daughter...

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

Excellent work! A little sad not seeing a Logitech mouse in the list there ;) I'm a huge fan of the G9 but IMO what mouse you use is entirely personal preference.

Again, excellent work--very well done.

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/1715969.png
Reply to dirtdiver

Thats a lot of information guys .Thanks a lot .Very informative.


las vegas towing

Reply to Bestprice

This was great for me, I am looking to buy the budget intel build, but these two items are sold out on newegg:

# HSF: COOLER MASTER Intel Core i5 & Intel Core i7 compatible RR-B10-212P-GP 120mm "heatpipe direct contact" Long life sleeve CPU ... - Retail
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6835103065
# HDD: SAMSUNG Spinpoint F3 HD502HJ 500GB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s 3.5" Internal Hard Drive - OEM
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6822152181

Any recommendation as to a part to get in their place or should I wait? How long does newegg usually take to re-stock?


Message edited by opsayo on 11-18-2009 at 09:17:57 AM
Reply to opsayo

I use the Xigmatek Dark Knight 120mm HDT cooler, and I love it. Keeps my OC'd E8400 at about 36-39C Idle and doesn't have extra "bling" aside from a single white LED that is hardly noticeable.

$44 -- http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] -_-Product

Using with socket 1156 will require this bracket for $8 -- http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] -_-Product

the bracket kit appears to be out of stock on newegg, but you can snag it anywhere (like the cooler itself).

It has direct touch heatpipes, and a 120mm fan with rubber mounts for quiet operation. It is BIG, if your case has a side-venting fan you may need to relocate it (slap in on the outside of the case) or remove it.

I recommend this cooler though, I really do like it a lot.

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/1715969.png
Reply to dirtdiver

The xigmatec bracket kit seems to be a problem right now. Xigmatec said the shipment they were supposed to get last week is stuck in customs or something.

Xigmatec also has the S1283 Rifle cooler (which is the Dark knight without the black nickel finish). It needs the same bracket for an 1156.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6835233003


You could always run on the stock cooler until the hyper212 or xiggy brackets get restocked.

Reply to dndhatcher

Why yes, the rifle does look just like the dark knight lol. I hadn't noticed that! I do not like how newegg doesn't have a picture of the base of the Rifle HSF though. Although it says HDT I would really like to see that before I buy--it is one of the reasons I grabbed the dark knight.

I would run stock until the Xigmatek's are available (I actually DID run stock until they were available, lol).

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/1715969.png
Reply to dirtdiver

The Xigmatek Dark Knight (S1283V), Red Scorpion (RS1283) and Balder (SD1283) are all S1283 Rifle cooler models with different fans or coatings. I really like the looks of the Balder with the silver nickel coating and white LED fan but they dont seem to sell it in the US.


Message edited by dndhatcher on 11-19-2009 at 07:08:32 PM
Reply to dndhatcher

I read the review on that a while back on Guru3D. Looks like a cool mouse--but I am hooked on the G9.

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/1715969.png
Reply to dirtdiver

I feel that this thread has several weaknesses. Primarily, it completely defeats the purpose of the "How to Ask for Build Advice" sticky. Meaning, you just suggest builds without knowing any of the things that are required in order to build the best PC for someone. You don't know what the person's resolution is, whether they plan on overclocking or crossfire/sli, what parts they prefer, or anything. Also, your title, "Recommended Builds By Usage" doesn't really make sense - the only factor you consider is price. I appreciate all the effort you put into this, I'm just explaining my feelings about it.

Reply to jbl91

jbl91 wrote :

I feel that this thread has several weaknesses. Primarily, it completely defeats the purpose of the "How to Ask for Build Advice" sticky. Meaning, you just suggest builds without knowing any of the things that are required in order to build the best PC for someone. You don't know what the person's resolution is, whether they plan on overclocking or crossfire/sli, what parts they prefer, or anything. Also, your title, "Recommended Builds By Usage" doesn't really make sense - the only factor you consider is price. I appreciate all the effort you put into this, I'm just explaining my feelings about it.


Thank you for your comments. This thread is not design to replace or go against the "How to Ask for Build Advice" sticky. It is to be used in conjunction with the sticky. A OP can review my thread get an idea of what they can build based on their budget, use one of my "pre-build" options, and use it to ask how does it fit their needs in accordance to The Animal's sticky. A reader has the option to build start up one of my recommendations, since they have done research up front an it meets their needs. I could not develope builds to address all possible resolutions, budgets, or usages of a possible OP.

The title comes from the definitions of "Bargain, Budget, Gamer, & Enthusiast". Based on information & thoughts between sKora and me, I developed builds I felt met those definitions / usages. I seperated them by cost in my mind because I'm not going to build a bargain PC and spend $1,000 or build an enthusiast PC for less than $600.

I hope that helps you understand a little more on the purpose, thoughts behind it & how to use this sticky.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

The GPU link on the budget intel is showing a deactivated item which could be out of stock or discontinued...link to new product please?

Reply to Xenocity

jbl91 wrote :

I feel that this thread has several weaknesses. Primarily, it completely defeats the purpose of the "How to Ask for Build Advice" sticky. Meaning, you just suggest builds without knowing any of the things that are required in order to build the best PC for someone. You don't know what the person's resolution is, whether they plan on overclocking or crossfire/sli, what parts they prefer, or anything. Also, your title, "Recommended Builds By Usage" doesn't really make sense - the only factor you consider is price. I appreciate all the effort you put into this, I'm just explaining my feelings about it.



While many visitors to Tom's have above average knowledge of PC parts few have in-depth expert level knowledge. Sometimes you need a reference point to even get to the point where you can ask the right question. Also with the millions of posts here at Tom's it is often impossible to find an answer to your question because you don't know which search terms to use. Furthermore with a myriad of variations for every part used in a PC (Newegg list 79 CPUs) that have very subtle differences, having someone "tell" you what to buy is a useful starting point.

I recently read in an graphics card article that while two card SLI is great, a VERY small percentage of people actually use it. I just bought a MoBo for a build that can do NVIDIA Hybrid SLI but I'm having trouble finding any information on what cards I can use to do it. Probably because, while the feature is there, no one is using it.

I still contend that MacWrite, which had the operating system AND the application on a 720Kb floppy, is more word processor than 90% of users will ever need. That said, most systems are way overbuilt for what they will actually be used for. Sure there are many serious gamers and games are designed for those users, but recommending a build based on generalities is a useful starting point for most people.

Most people will use a standard resolution which the vast majority of graphics chips can produce. They won't overclock or use two graphics cards, they prefer the lowest priced brand they can find, etc. While there are hundreds (maybe thousands) of active users on Tom's, there are tens of millions of PC users whose biggest choice is "Mac or PC." (And since PC owns 90% of the market that isn't really much of a choice.)

I used Tom's to pick out the parts for my new HTPC. But I'm the exception in that I had the time to do that. I've been designing it for several months spending many hours reading articles and posts and checking prices, but the final decisions were made in a couple of hours during Newegg's Black Friday sale and they were based on price. Most people who will build their own system (I wonder how many do that?) will just look for recommendations from a trusted source (Tom's is the one I recommend) and buy parts as close to the recommended list as possible. They change one or two based on personal experience (I've never used AMD, I had many friends that worked for WD), friend's biases and prejudices, their budget, specific needs (I don't watch Blu-Ray movies or game) and availability. But for the most part they just want to say the built it themselves and saved some money.

These are my feelings on the topic and d@ng it, they sound harsh toward jbl91 and I didn't mean them to. jbl91 - I'm sorry but I don't have time to rewrite them. I have no ill feelings toward you. I usually write my comments offline, rewrite them for tone and then post them.

Reply to BlueCat57

Question: What they h??? is a "sticky"? I can make some guesses but haven't quite figured it out.

Suggestion: Having all these system builds in one thread allows comparison of the builds, but the ongoing suggestions begin to confuse. What about having all the builds in one thread and then a separate thread for each build in which the specifics are discussed?

Reply to BlueCat57

Sticky is simply the thread stays at the top of the forum's first page where is always visible when you visit the forum - Sticks to the top of the forum... sticky (I hope that helps... :D )

You will notice when a user responds to this post asking for guidance on a build, others or I will respond by requesting them to start their own thread with the desired questions. A user should not post in this thread asking for build advice, which should be done in separate thread. A user can post comments (such as you have) or recommended parts or changes to my builds (as other have). Those suggestions can help make the initial information on the first page more useful, current and point out options I might have missed or didn't think about. A user can feel free to take a build and start a separate thread and open it up for discussions. We wouldn't be able to have this sticky and each build broken down into it's own sticky... 1) the moderators won't allow that many stickies 2) You would lose track of intent of the original sticky, which is to give a recommended build (without taking into account combo's, MIR... etc), not specific builds that are good for a specific time frame.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

Quote :

Bargain: $51191 - This socket is still a good bargain build CPU due to it's OCing Abilities (Thanks for the feedback... 4ryan6)


!!

Reply to psycho sykes

Well... 4ryan6 said it was a bargain at $51191 and who am I to question a moderator?? [:jaydeejohn:4]




Okay... I fixed my typo to $511.91

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

:lol:


Anyway What do you think about an ION based HTPC?

Reply to psycho sykes

^ low power consumption space saver. That is about it lol.

------------------------------ http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/1715969.png
Reply to dirtdiver

You need to make sure the ION will do what you want it to. Some versions won't do full-screen online videos. Tom's has some articles and forum posts that talk about that.

Basing an HTPC on ION is going to really limit the upgradability of the system. Starting with a separate CPU and MoBo you can add a discrete graphics card if you decide you want to do gaming. And with a discrete graphics card you can keep up with the changing standards for video and sound output. And when that CPU seems to slow, just upgrade it and the RAM and you've got what will feel like a new system.

Reply to BlueCat57

Thanks for the great up to date info. It's very helpful.

I am considering putting together something similar to the intel gaming system. I'm just wondering about the PSU. When I go here http://www.antec.outervision.com/PSUEngine as well as another caculator they tell me that I need about 350W of power yet your builds have 750W PSUs. I don't plan on doing any over clocking. Is it possible to go with a lower wattage high quality PSU?

Thanks!

Reply to marlz

marlz wrote :

Thanks for the great up to date info. It's very helpful.

I am considering putting together something similar to the intel gaming system. I'm just wondering about the PSU. When I go here http://www.antec.outervision.com/PSUEngine as well as another caculator they tell me that I need about 350W of power yet your builds have 750W PSUs. I don't plan on doing any over clocking. Is it possible to go with a lower wattage high quality PSU?

Thanks!


Yes, you can switch to a lower wattage PSU. I would recommend not dropping below 550W for the PSU. My builds have a 750W PSU to give the user the option to Crossfire/SLI down the road.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

Thanks for the great build guide -- I followed the extreme enthusiast almost exclusively.

However, I believe there is a compatibility issue in the CPU and MB combo you have chosen.

I got the core i7 specified, and the Asus P6T deluxe V2. Now I learn that the new "D0" core i7 (S-spec SLBEJ) requires ASUS bios version 0302...and the P6T sold to me via Newegg last week was 0102.

The result? It won't boot at all, so you cannot flash the BIOS! ASUS is recommending I take the MB to a computer shop and have the board booted with an older C0 core i7 and have the BIOS flashed that way! Otherwise, a new BIOS chip must be purchased, or sent from ASUS (for a fee), and installed at home. Either way, I pay extra -- and get a delay -- to make the MB function with a cpu it is advertised as working with out of the box.

A real catch-22 situation, but the bottom line is that until ASUS ships its MBs with BIOS 0302 -- and none being sold are now that version -- the combo listed in your build will not boot.

Otherwise, great list of products, and I appreciated it.

(For a description of the problem on the ASUS user forum, check here at post #12: http://vip.asus.com/forum/view.asp [...] us&page=2)

Reply to MrMyke

MrMyke wrote :

Thanks for the great build guide -- I followed the extreme enthusiast almost exclusively.

However, I believe there is a compatibility issue in the CPU and MB combo you have chosen.

I got the core i7 specified, and the Asus P6T deluxe V2. Now I learn that the new "D0" core i7 (S-spec SLBEJ) requires ASUS bios version 0302...and the P6T sold to me via Newegg last week was 0102.

The result? It won't boot at all, so you cannot flash the BIOS! ASUS is recommending I take the MB to a computer shop and have the board booted with an older C0 core i7 and have the BIOS flashed that way! Otherwise, a new BIOS chip must be purchased, or sent from ASUS (for a fee), and installed at home. Either way, I pay extra -- and get a delay -- to make the MB function with a cpu it is advertised as working with out of the box.

A real catch-22 situation, but the bottom line is that until ASUS ships its MBs with BIOS 0302 -- and none being sold are now that version -- the combo listed in your build will not boot.

Otherwise, great list of products, and I appreciated it.

(For a description of the problem on the ASUS user forum, check here at post #12: http://vip.asus.com/forum/view.asp [...] us&page=2)


MrMyke,

Thanks for reviewing my thread and basing a build off of my extreme enthusiast build!! :D

I am sorry to hear that you ran into an issue with the build that the ASUS P6T Deluxe V2 didn't support the DO stepping of the i7 920. I have not heard of any compatibility issue with the CPU and MOBO until you hightligthed. :( I hope you are able to get your issue resolved quickly and with little or no expense out of your pocket. I have updated the MOBO for this build to the new ASUS motherboard supporting USB 3.0 and SATA 6Gb/s. It was roughly an additional $60 on the build and will provide the ability to utilize these components down the road.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

Well, thats a negative point to ASUSs support. When I messed up the BIOS chip for my DFI motherboard, the email tech support guy had me mail it to DFI and they flashed it and mailed it back at no cost (other than mailing). You would think ASUS could do the same since you have no control over which BIOS revision your board will have when you order it.

Reply to dndhatcher

^ Agreed. Not like Asus to take the piss like that. Too bad though. Perhaps try their support again, see if you catch someone who is in a helpful mood!

Reply to dirtdiver

I just purchased the Budget build that uses the intel i5 processor. All my parts came in and since this is my first PC put together, I messed up a few times. I took it into the shop and it worked - so all my parts came in functioning :)

I have something to say however - the case has a mounted fan on the side panel which does not fit with the very large cooler master heat sink. I guess I have to take off the mounted fan. Just something I thought the person who made this thread should know.

All in all, thank you for the great advice and other than that everything has worked perfectly!

Cheers!

Reply to opsayo

opsayo wrote :

I just purchased the Budget build that uses the intel i5 processor. All my parts came in and since this is my first PC put together, I messed up a few times. I took it into the shop and it worked - so all my parts came in functioning :)

I have something to say however - the case has a mounted fan on the side panel which does not fit with the very large cooler master heat sink. I guess I have to take off the mounted fan. Just something I thought the person who made this thread should know.

All in all, thank you for the great advice and other than that everything has worked perfectly!

Cheers!


Thank you for the heads up on the case side fan and HSF issue. I wasn't aware of that potential issue. I'll review my options for another case or heat sink fan to correct this issue.

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

Antec 200 might be a good option. It doesnt include front fans, but they can be added if someone has a cooling problem.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by dndhatcher on 12-28-2009 at 07:31:06 PM
Reply to dndhatcher

dndhatcher wrote :

Antec 200 might be a good option. It doesnt include front fans, but they can be added if someone has a cooling problem.


You read my mind... My last update I switched it out to the Antec 200... :D

------------------------------ Recommended Builds by Usage
Step-by-Step Guide to Building a PC
Reply to tecmo34

I began putting together the "Enthusiast" build. I noticed the chip did not appear to remotely even fit onto the motherboard.

This is the recommended chip: Intel Core i7-860 Lynnfield 2.8GHz 8MB L3 Cache LGA 1156 95W Quad-Core Processor - Retail
[url=http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115214][/url]. Note the LGA 1156 bit.

The recommended board is: GIGABYTE GA-P55M-UD4 LGA 1156 Intel P55 Micro ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail[url=http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128404][/url]. Also LGA 1156.

Unfortunately (for me, who didn't double/triple check everything myself) the clicking on the motherboard link sends you to this board:

ASUS P6T Deluxe V2 LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail[url=http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131365][/url] ... which is LGA 1366.

Can you update the link?

The good news is that the price for the correct mobo (and the total cost shown) is $130 cheaper.

Regards,

Stephan

Reply to stephan2
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > Homebuilt > [Solved] Recommended Builds by Usage
Go to:

There are 166 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Latest best answer
Son
By pdxalex, 16 days ago:

I'm not familiar with the HW2 or HST1 but some years ago when I had a Sony camcorder I...

They won a badge
Join us in greeting them