Ad
News

Microsoft Intros Fashion Statement Mice and Keyboards

Published on April 28, 2003

In an "It's about Time" announcement late last week, Microsoft released four new four new special edition hardware products, which are available for retail purchase for a limited time only in trendy "icicle white and "matte black" colors. Read more

Apple launches black U2 iPod

Published on October 26, 2004

Apple Computer has launched a new offensive in the digital music business, updating its iPod digital music player with a feature that will allow it to display photos on a color screen and boosting the storage capacity of its top-end line. Read more

Sony introduces limited edition silver PlayStation 2

Published on October 30, 2006

Sony has released a limited edition silver-colored edition of its PlayStation 2 game console. Basically it's the same as the traditional black PlayStation 2 console except for the silver sheen and silver DualShock 2 analog controller. Read more

Iomega rolls out two Mac only drives

Published on December 19, 2006

Iomega, a company famous for making portable drives, has introduced two new drives for Macintosh users. The big UltraMax desktop drive has an impressive 1 TB of capacity while the portable Iomega 'Black' drive can hold 120 GB. Both drives include EMC's Retrospect Express backup software. Read more

Last Reviews & Articles

System Builder Marathon: Performance & Value

Published on November 28, 2008

We tightened the budget on this month’s enthusiast-level system while loosening our belt for the low-cost gamer box by a similar percentage. Today we gauge the effect of these changes on performance and value and compare to last month's machines. Read more

System Builder Marathon: $1,250 Enthusiast PC

Published on November 27, 2008

On this, the second day of our System Builder Marathon, Don turns down the price tag of his mid-range build looking for a sweet spot just above the $1,000 marker. Let's see what sort of hardware he found for it! Read more

System Builder Marathon: $625 Gaming PC

Published on November 26, 2008

This month's System Builder Marathon is all about your feedback to us. We've revamped our entry-level and mid-range PCs with new price points. Let's kick things off with what we think is the best value at a $625 price point! Read more

The State Of The Personal Computer

Published on November 25, 2008

Where were we in 2008 and where are we heading in 2009? In his State of the Personal Computer address, Alan Dang shares his insights as a user of three different platforms--Mac, Windows, and Linux. Read more

  Tom's Hardware UK and Ireland Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » E7200 or Amd 5400 black edition
 

E7200 or Amd 5400 black edition

Advanced Search

There are 368 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here



Should i get a e7200 core 2 duo or a Amd 5400+BE


 
12.5 %
      2 votes
AMD Athlon X2 5400+ (Black Edition)
 
 
87.5 %
      14 votes
Intel Core 2 Duo E7200
 

All : 18 votes (2 blank votes)
Poll with 10 possible answers.
This poll is closed, you cannot vote
Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : E7200 or Amd 5400 black edition
 
Profile: stranger
More Information

Should I get a e7200 with a 60 dollar motherboard or a Amd 5400+BE with an 80 motherboard. With the AMD i would overclock it and the Intel will probably stay at stock or small overclock. or is there another possibility for the same price?

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Profile: Forum Resident
More Information

blessthefall wrote :

Should I get a e7200 with a 60 dollar motherboard or a Amd 5400+BE with an 80 motherboard. With the AMD i would overclock it and the Intel will probably stay at stock or small overclock. or is there another possibility for the same price?





Unless you have a preference fo rone vendor or another and to keept eh flames down, I'd say toss a coin. Either way you'll get a capable system.

Profile: addict
More Information

I voted for the x2 5400+ because you can get a really nice mobo like one of these ...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] =2&bop=And

Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

An OC'd 5400+ would likely beat an Non-OC'd E7200.

But why you would not want to OC a Chip that can hit 4.0Ghz Fairly easily from 2.5Ghz boggles my mind..............


---------------
If its good in theory but not in practice,
its not good theory.
Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

zenmaster wrote :

An OC'd 5400+ would likely beat an Non-OC'd E7200.

But why you would not want to OC a Chip that can hit 4.0Ghz Fairly easily from 2.5Ghz boggles my mind..............


That's exactly what I was thinking.

Behind every great man, lies a lot of death
Profile: member
More Information

of course get the AMD.

Easy overclock. You will probably reach 3.1-3.3 GHz if using aftermarket cooling. Get the 780G motherboard so you can get the SB700 southbridge so later if you decide to swap to phenom to be able to overclock more.

Intel CPU with $60 motherboard will be just extremely inappropriate.

"Couldnt think of one"
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

e7200 in my opinion would be better. lower temps and much more headroom for overclock. Both cpus are good at there respected prices.
Good luck.
=]


---------------
intel core 2 quad q6600 @3.2ghz msi p6n diamond (X-FI Extreme sound) 6gig of OCZ+CoRSAIR oc 900mhz Nvidia gtx 260 sli @ 712/1260
Lite-On Blue-ray Western Digital 7200rpm 500gb Antec 500 Earthwatt Window vista 64-bit
Profile: old hand
More Information

he won;t be able to OC the e7200 with a cheap motherboard, it won't let him

maybe if you can get a p43? i wouldn;t know if that is a good OC'ing motherboard

cjl
Rocket Scientist
Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

Get the Intel and a cheap P35 board. You should easily get it up to 3.2GHz even on a cheap board, and likely significantly higher.

Profile: stranger
More Information

the reason why i wont be able to OC the e7200 is because i don't have the money to get a expensive motherboard and a high end aftermarket heat sink.however in the future i might get a better aftermarket heat sink and then try OCing it .

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by blessthefall on 08-13-2008 at 09:16:34 PM
Profile: member
More Information

Go for the e7200. No need for more performance at the moment, in the future get the new heatsink and overclock, it's a fair bit better than the 5400.

Profile: member
More Information

Overclock it too 3 ghz with stock heatsink. Just don't bump the v core.

AMD is woefully deficent at overclocking compared to any of intels chips, at any price level.

A biostar t force for 79.99 is both reliable and a good overclocker. P43 chipset with DDR2 1066 and PCI E 2.0 support. The ASRock twin board at the same price looks good but only has a few reviews and those are some what mixed.

Profile: member
More Information

if you buy the 5400+ BE you HAVE to buy an aftermarket heat sink/cooler

so add at least $30 to the cost of the 5400+

but with the e7200 you can overclock with the stock cooler and reach the same speeds that you would with the amd with the aftermarket solution

so if you get the e7200 you're already saving $30 by not getting the heatsink/cooler
you can use that $30 to buy a better motherboard
then 2 or 3 months from now when you have extra cash you can buy a cooler and really crank up the e7200 way past anything the 5400+ could reach

you should get 3.4 on the e7200 pretty easily with just the stock cooler

http://www.ocforums.com/showthread.php?t=558023

http://www.ocforums.com/showthread [...] ight=e7200


Message edited by jamesl on 08-13-2008 at 09:54:08 PM
There is ALWAYS a drone.
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

What is the purpose of this build? The GPU may end up making a bigger final difference in performance, in which case get whichever is cheaper. If there will be little to no gaming, the AMD on a 780G board is awfully tempting for cheap, but if you will get a discrete GPU anyway, may as well go for the Intel on a P43 or P35.


---------------
There is ALWAYS a drone. Exactly where, or how many drones you will encounter may vary, but that there will be at least one will not.
Profile: stranger
More Information

DEFINITELY E7200!

it's MUCH better for OC! I can run my E7200 at 3.3ghz at stock voltage (55 degrees full load with stock cooler) . and I've only got a $95 gigabyte p35 mobo

the E7200 has a FSB of 1066 (266mhz) with a 9.5x multiplier, but almost all intel motherboards today that supports 45nm processors supports fsb 1333 (333mhz), which means by simply setting the fsb to 333mhz in the bios, you achieve a clock speed of 3.16ghz!

the amd is unlocked but it has a higher TDP and it's much more difficult to achieve high overclocks.

I'm currently running my e7