Raid 0 performance - Seagate with AAK firmware

News

Seagate Files IPO Application

Published on October 15, 2002

In a gutsy move in the sluggish technology market, Seagate Technology Holdings has filed an S-1 with the S.E.C. Read more

3ware Launches Second Generation Performance-Driven Serial ATA RAID

Published on July 15, 2003

3ware Inc., a leading provider of high-capacity, switched Serial ATA (SATA) RAID storage solutions, today announced the availability of its second generation SATA RAID controllers - the Escalade(tm) 8506 series, and sixth generation Parallel RAID controllers - the Escalade 7506 series. Read more

Seagate Unveils Plans for 2.5" Enterprise Disc Drives

Published on May 20, 2003

Seagate announced a new 2.5" enterprise disc drive platform. Read more

D-Link Upgrades Xtreme G Firmware

Published on August 07, 2003

D-Link today released new firmware bringing the D-Link AirPlus Xtreme G Wireless networking products in strict compliance with the IEEE 802.11g standard. Read more

Last Reviews & Articles

Intel's Core i7: Blazing Fast, But Crippled O/C

Published on November 03, 2008

Core i7--previously referred to as Nehalem--requires new motherboards, coolers and memory. Its performance is compelling and means AMD is falling behind even further, but Intel is putting in some speed bumps that will impact overclocking enthusiasts. Read more

System Builder Marathon: Performance and Value

Published on October 31, 2008

Three dramatically different builds face off in show of performance, defining the real value of each. Our mainstream system is designed to meet the needs of most users. Who should spend more and who can live with less? Read more

System Builder Marathon: $500 Gaming PC

Published on October 30, 2008

On this, the second to last day of our System Builder Marathon series, we add a $500 gaming PC to the mix. It's not going to be as quick as our other two builds, but we think Paul was able to get some serious value from this thing. Read more

Tom's SBM: The $1,500 Mainstream PC

Published on October 29, 2008

We're following up yesterday's $4,500 behemoth with a more affordable $1,500 mid-range build. Let's see what sort of performance (and overclocking headroom) you can get when you spend one third of the money. Read more

All the Reviews & Articles

Relatives contents

Tom's Hardware UK and Ireland Forums » Storage » NAS/RAID & Technologies » Raid 0 performance - Seagate with AAK firmware

Raid 0 performance - Seagate with AAK firmware

Advanced Search

There are 446 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here

Word : Username : Filter :
Bottom
Author	Thread : Raid 0 performance - Seagate with AAK firmware

crc79

Profile: stranger

More Information

08-31-2007 at 08:40:00 PM

Here's my story of going from poor performance with Seagate Barracuda drives with AAK firmware to good performance with Western Digital RE2's.

I just built a new gaming system for myself (based on the current Bang for the Buck PC on Extremetech) and initially had just bought one Seagate Barracuda 320GB hard drive. My HD Tach benchmark performance was a little disappointing (around 55-60 MB/s read), so I decided to go with RAID 0 to improve loading times. I had never run RAID before, so this was fun to research and set up.

Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3R
Hard drives: 2x Seagate 320GB Barracuda 7200.10 SATA II w/ NCQ, 16MB Cache - ST3320620AS

I set up everything correctly as far as I could tell:
- took off the SATA rate limiting jumpers to enable full 3GB SATA
- set it up on the ICH9R controller's yellow ports instead of the purple Gigabyte controller ones
- stripe size 16k
- enabled volume write back cache
- updated all the drivers

Benchmark performance was surprisingly bad, so I knew something was up. Check out these HD Tach results:

(flat graph, average read 86.4 MB/s)

I found an article detailing problems with Seagate AAK firmware and discovered both hard drives had AAK firmware.

It had been over 30 days since I bought the drives, so I was pushing it in terms of being able to get an exchange. Seagate said there wasn't an update available for it, but luckily my local computer store was cool about it and let me pay the difference to get some new drives. I brought them a copy of the article, which helped out I think.. graphs are always good.

I upgraded to Western Digital 500GB RE2 RAID Edition (WD5000YS) hard drives, did a clean install again and updated drivers. Here are the results. Nothing else about the setup has changed.

(Normal curved graph, average read 130.5 MB/s)

So, there you go! It's a bit more expensive, but I'm satisfied with these results. Hope this helps out others in this situation!

Message edited by crc79 on 08-31-2007 at 08:51:30 PM

Related Product

Greg_Clark

Profile: stranger

More Information

09-07-2007 at 01:47:00 AM

Hide

We will fight them in the flow charts!
We will fight them in the spreadsheets!
We will fight them in the graphs!

enlightenment

Profile: journeyman

More Information

09-25-2007 at 03:52:57 PM

Hide

Any reason you picked a stripesize of 16KB? That is very low and will limit performance of your array. I suggest taking 64KB or 128KB. Though bad controllers will read all the data in a stripe even when only 1KB is needed, that's the downside of picking a larger stripesize. But i believe Intel ICH9R does not suffer from this.

---------------
With sufficient enlightenment we can give substance to any distinction: mind without body, north without south, pleasure without pain.

sdk1985

Profile: stranger

More Information

04-01-2008 at 11:03:17 PM

Hide

Ok I have the exact same problem with my Seagate Barracude 7200.10 (AAK firmware as that seems to be the problem). Also in raid 0...

http://img440.imageshack.us/my.php?image=hdtachdv5.jpg

Tom's Hardware UK and Ireland Forums » Storage » NAS/RAID & Technologies » Raid 0 performance - Seagate with AAK firmware

Go to:

Page generated in 0.476 seconds

Google ads