Ad
News

WD Raptor Goes Retail!

Published on May 14, 2003

Western Digital announced that the Company's Enterprise Serial ATA WD Raptor hard drives are available now in retail stores and at its online store at store.westerndigital.com. Read more

Maxtor bypasses the PC

Published on August 31, 2005

Disk drive maker Maxtor challenged the concept of a personal computer as a home entertainment media server by unveiling on Wednesday a hard drive equipped with specialized networking software that reduces the concept of an entertainment server to its bare essentials. Read more

Western Digital Announces SATA Enterprise 10,000 RPM Raptor Series

Published on February 10, 2003

This morning, Western Digital announced that it is entering the Enterprise hard drive market with the release of its new Raptor Series Enterprise Level SATA hard drives. Read more

Asustek releases AP1710 server

Published on July 11, 2003

Asustek Computer today introduced the AP1710 server series. Read more

Last Reviews & Articles

Power Supply Roundup: Part II

Published on November 07, 2008

In Part I of our power supply roundup, we went through five mainstream PSUs rated at up to 700 W. Round two sees us tackle another seven mid-range units in an effort to determine which power supply deserves your attention. Read more

Roundup: The Best Overclocking Software

Published on November 06, 2008

Interested in overclocking but not quite sure where to start? We round up some of our favorite software utilities for tweaking processors, memory, graphics, and chipsets. Read more

Tom's Holiday Buyer's Guide 2008, Part 1

Published on November 05, 2008

Welcome to the first installment in our six-part Tom's Holiday Buyer's Guide. In Part 1, two beautiful models help showcase some of our favorite no-hassle hardware gifts for 2008. Read more

Round Up: Five Powerful, Light Ultraportables

Published on November 05, 2008

Executives, road warriors, and gadget geeks all lust after ultraportable notebooks. Five of these amazing machines battle it out in this roundup. Read more

  Tom's Hardware UK and Ireland Forums » Storage » General Storage » AS a server, WD 750 gig drive vs raptor
 

AS a server, WD 750 gig drive vs raptor

Advanced Search

There are 169 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here



Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : AS a server, WD 750 gig drive vs raptor
 
Profile: stranger
More Information

I'm building a server (web server, ftp server, etc) using a Q6600.
Which storage solution best serve my needs, WD 750 gig drive or raptor?

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by yongsiklee on 07-16-2007 at 10:26:46 PM
Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Profile: old hand
More Information

yongsiklee wrote :

I'm building a server (web server, ftp server, etc) using a Q6600.
Which storage solution best serve my needs, WD 750 gig drive or raptor?



The raptor is faster, the 7200 drive has more capacity.

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

ethel wrote :

The raptor is faster, the 7200 drive has more capacity.



100% agree, quick access times definetly help. and for a performance server, the raptor would make more sense too (since that seems is the point of it, because there are larger hdds than the 750GB out)


Message edited by choirbass on 07-16-2007 at 11:21:30 PM
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

You could get two 300 or 400 gig drives and do a raid for performance/integrity... depending on the board you have. Cheaper then Raptor, and faster I believe.

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

grieve wrote :

You could get two 300 or 400 gig drives and do a raid for performance/integrity... depending on the board you have. Cheaper then Raptor, and faster I believe.



the only problem with that, is that the 750GB already offers marginally higher STRs than the raptors do. but when it comes to overall application performance and responsiveness, high STRs alone usually arent what matter, more the opposite actually.


Message edited by choirbass on 07-17-2007 at 12:13:04 AM
Profile: old hand
More Information

For servers, sustained transfer rate (STR) is only a piece of the puzzle. Access time and I/O Operations per second (IOPs) mean more than STR.

Obviously, the Raptor has the advantage in access time over the 7200 RPM drives due to the higher (10K RPM) rotational speed. (The Raptor's advantage goes up even more if the 7200 RPM drives are in a RAID, because the access to data time goes up when you use RAID).

As far as IOPs, the Raptors destroy every other SATA drive on the market. Take a look on that StorageReview page at the "IOMeter File Server - 2 IOs" and "IOMeter File Server - 4 IOs" benchmarks. These two tests represent a lightly and medium-loaded server, respectively. As you will see, there is a large group of SCSI and SAS drives on top, then all the WD Raptors, then all the cannon fodder. :)

By the way, we're talking about the Raptor(s) here to be used for the data drive(s) on the server - i.e. the drive where the server's content is going to be served from (be that web pages, files, or whatever). The system drive of the server matters a lot less, and in fact is generally chosen to be in a RAID 1 configuration for redundancy.


Message edited by SomeJoe7777 on 07-17-2007 at 04:27:50 AM

---------------
- SomeJoe7777

"Did he dazzle you with his extensive knowledge of mineral water? Or was it his in-depth analysis of, uh, uh, Marky Mark that finally reeled you in?" - Troy Dyer (Ethan Hawke), Reality Bites, 1994
Profile: member
More Information

What's the network speed and architecture?
Is the network card a slow old PCI bus or one of the newer PCI-e cards?
No point in having a fast HD if the network is going to bottle-neck.

Profile: stranger
More Information

My internet speed is 15mb download and 2mb upload.
This server is only accessable from WAN.

I didn't buy a network card yet and I didn't know if I need a "faster" network card. And I didn't know a PCI network card would be an issue here.

This server is mainly for a web server to browse through.

Profile: stranger
More Information

And another thing: Is Gigabit ethernet card is the same as PCIe network card?

Profile: stranger
More Information

How about this: Intel® PRO/1000 PT Desktop Adapter?

f61
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Good Choice.
BTW: what board are you using?


Message edited by f61 on 07-19-2007 at 12:26:25 PM

---------------
Vista=W98se...LOL just say no to scripts, and ActiveX controls at the right time. You guess when.

The iPhone's battery is soldered into place. Thats OK if you drop it, it won't fall out. How much will it cost to swap?
Profile: old hand
More Information

yongsiklee wrote :

My internet speed is 15mb download and 2mb upload.



2 Mb upload is low enough that virtually any network card will work just fine. I was under the impression that this was an internal server or was going to be doing some work on a LAN, not a WAN.

yongsiklee wrote :

And another thing: Is Gigabit ethernet card is the same as PCIe network card?



No. PCIe is the slot interface. It's newer and faster than PCI. Gigabit refers to the network (Ethernet) speed. Gigabit = 1000 Mb/sec, vs. most other network cards which are Fast Ethernet = 100 Mb/sec.

yongsiklee wrote :

How about this: Intel® PRO/1000 PT Desktop Adapter?



Excellent network card, but a bit overkill for this application.

Given that this server is going to serve web pages and not files, and will be doing so over a 2Mb WAN connection, the server's requirements are lightened considerably. You probably will serve the web pages just fine using a mid-range network card, and don't necessarily need a Raptor or other enterprise level hard drive. How much enterprise-level equipment you want to use is somewhat dependent on how many hits you get to the site and how mission critical the reliability of the server is, so you may have to use your best judgement there.


---------------
- SomeJoe7777

"Did he dazzle you with his extensive knowledge of mineral water? Or was it his in-depth analysis of, uh, uh, Marky Mark that finally reeled you in?" - Troy Dyer (Ethan Hawke), Reality Bites, 1994

  Tom's Hardware UK and Ireland Forums » Storage » General Storage » AS a server, WD 750 gig drive vs raptor

Go to:
 

Google ads