Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No

Test Results

by

All processors get extremely hot when the CPU fan is switched off, and you will find the Northbridge reaching almost 70°C - even more than that if you measure the temperature on the processor heat sink. We simply ran the test systems laying flat on the test bench table, which doesn’t provide any airflow at all. We used the stock coolers and disconnected the CPU fan as we started the individual benchmarks.

PCMark 05

The only system configuration that could actually finish PCMark 05 without a working processor cooler was the Pentium Dual Core E2160. Every other processor, whether AMD or Intel, shut down the system after only a few minutes. The temperature we measured at around the CPU heat sink exceeded 70°C.

Even the CPU benchmark, which puts every processor to work rather intensively, finished on the Pentium Dual Core E2160, though at clearly reduced performance (3375 instead of 4658 points). Obviously, the Thermal Monitor feature was working well, shutting off the processor when it was about to overheat. The reason that the Core 2 Duo E6850 didn’t finish is probably its much higher clock speed level (FSB1333 and 3.0 GHz as opposed to FSB8000 and 1.8 GHz) combined with the quadrupled L2 cache size of 4 MB (instead of 1 MB).

We received the same results with the memory benchmark of PCMark 05.

Share:
2
Comments
Read more
X
Submit

Comments
Read the comments on the forums
polarity 27/09/2007 22:36
Hide
-0+

Potential fan failure is a good reason to use a push/pull fan set up on a tower CPU cooler.

I've yet to have a CPU fan fail as I've always bought quality fans with ball bearings, but if you use sleeve bearing fans, or have a problem with dust then the fans is a lot more likely to fail.

digitalsi 08/10/2007 19:09
Hide
-0+

This is very interesting. I am suprised that the Athlon BE series does not run cooler than the Pentium DC.

All of this begs the question - If I want to build a system with decent performance (read: modern dual core CPU), but I want it completely silent, which CPU, and which heatsink would I have to buy?

I am presuming that a 3rd party heatsink might provide enough cooling to enable some of these CPUs to run without a fan without throttling.

Best offers

Newsletters


OK