Game Benchmarks, Continued.
Source: Tom's Hardware – Keywords: ati, agp, 3850, agp
Game Benchmarks, Continued.

Once again, the 6600 GT is unplayable. What’s interesting is that the UT3 engine seems to favor the Radeon 2600 XT’s universal shader power over the X1950 PRO’s superior memory bandwidth. If the performance bump was attributable to the 2600 XT’s PCIe interface, the difference between the AGP 3850 and the underclocked PCIe 3870 would have been noticeable.
We’re also seeing a continuation of the same theme: while the 3800 series cards get the highest frame rates of the bunch, the average is still abut 20 frames per second, not the 30 minimum we’d need for smooth gameplay.

Supreme Commander is known to be a heavily multithreaded game engine, and we can see all of the cards are being bottlenecked by the CPU, even at minimal detail settings. Even the 6600 GT performs almost as well as every other card we benchmarked. Because the game is a real time strategy title, and not a “twitch” game like a first person shooter, it’s playable—but not pretty.

Flight Simulator X is the only game that suggests any possible evidence of the AGP 8x interface acting as a bottleneck; both the PCIe 2600 XT and underclocked PCIe 3870 show a slight but consistent lead over the other cards. However, there’s clearly a CPU bottleneck in this title as well, and the game is barely playable at the maximum settings.
- Previous page Game Benchmarks
- Next page Video Decoding Benchmarks
- GPU vs. CPU Upgrade: Extensive Tests
- NForce 780a SLI Debuts Hybrid SLI
- How To Overclock Your Graphics Card
- PCI Express 2.0 Graphics Cards: How Much Extra Performance Do They...
- Nvidia GeForce 9800 GTX Review
- Nvidia GeForce 9800 GX2 Review
- The Best Gaming Graphics cards for Your Money: March 2008
- Nvidia's GeForce 9600 GT Reviewed
- Fresh from Canada - ATI's Radeon HD 3450 and HD 3650
- The Best Gaming Graphics Cards for Your Money: February 2008
Interesting review. I have at home an old rig: Amd64 3800+ single core,Gigabyte K8N-PRO sli mobo, 2gb ram, X1900gt pci express, Seagate 320gb sata hdd and a 560W chieftec psu. I am planning to wait untill next year to replace it with a new one but I would like to squeeze some more juice out of it by buying a new graphic card: Ati 3870, NVidia 9600gt or a Ati 3850?
Which would do better?
Any chance of seeing part 2 of this study this year? I have an Athlon X2 3800 and a 1950 Pro, and would like to be sure that a 3850 is the way to go for the next year rather than blowing £400 on a new PCIe / DDR2 capable rig.
Thanks