Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in

Results: Greyscale Tracking And Gamma Response

Asus PB287Q 28-Inch 4K Monitor Review: Ultra HD For £600
By

The majority of monitors, especially newer models, display excellent greyscale tracking (even at stock settings). It’s important that the colour of white be consistently neutral at all light levels from darkest to brightest. Greyscale performance impacts colour accuracy with regard to the secondary colours: cyan, magenta, and yellow. Since computer monitors typically have no colour or tint adjustment, accurate greyscale is key.

We’re showing you the results from both Game and Standard modes.

Most monitors have picture modes optimized for specific applications like Game or Text, so we want to show you what happens in those modes. When you select Game on Asus' PB287Q, the greyscale tracking runs a little cool but isn’t too bad overall. Unlike some other displays, you can adjust the RGB sliders if you want to improve the result. When we get to the gamma and colour gamut measurements, you’ll get a better idea of what we’re trying to tell you.

When you select the User Color Temp preset, this is the level of performance you’ll see. There are no visible errors, but our i1Pro says the white point is a little on the cool side. Still, it's pretty much excellent for a measurement right out of the box.

By tweaking the RGB sliders a bit, we improved the tracking slightly. The greatest gains are at the bright end of the luminance scale. We also had to lower the Contrast control to clean up the 100-percent level. We’ve seen better greyscale charts. However, the PB287Q’s result raises no issues worth worrying about.

Back to the comparison group…

An un-calibrated error of 2.27 Delta E is well under the threshold of visibility. We would be perfectly happy using the PB287Q without adjustment. Of course, while it doesn’t need a calibration, we performed one anyway.

A result of 1.49 Delta E represents only a small improvement in greyscale performance. For some, the small reduction in contrast is too great of a price to pay for such a slight gain in accuracy. Remember that if you only adjust backlight intensity, you’ll see around 900 to 1 contrast, rather than the calibrated number of 764 to 1.

Gamma Response

Gamma is the measurement of luminance levels at every step in the brightness range from 0 to 100 percent. This is important because poor gamma can either crush detail at various points or wash it out, making the entire picture appear flat and dull. Correct gamma produces a more three-dimensional image, with a greater sense of depth and realism. Meanwhile, incorrect gamma can negatively affect image quality, even in monitors with high contrast ratios.

In the gamma charts below, the yellow line represents 2.2, which is the most widely used standard for television, film, and computer graphics production. The closer the white measurement trace comes to 2.2, the better.

We’re including three different traces to show the difference between Game and Standard mode, along with the effect of Asus' Smart View control.

In the charts above, you saw that the greyscale performance in Game mode wasn’t too bad. When it comes to measuring gamma, however, there's a clear price to be paid. The large dips at 10 and 90 percent mean detail in those ranges gets crushed. The impact on bright highlights is very obvious in real-world content.

Here is the gamma in Standard mode. It tracks very well and only runs slightly dark. The average value is 2.31, which is a tad higher than the preferred 2.2. The upside is that perceived contrast is a little better. Standard mode, without question, is the right choice for the best image quality.

Here’s what happens when you turn Smart View on:

I mentioned earlier that Smart View raises the black level and cuts overall contrast by 89 percent. The net effect is a flat and washed-out image with medium grey tones where black should be. It looks like Asus wants Smart View to help with shadow detail, but it would be more useful if the feature had four or five different levels rather than on/off.

Let's get back to the comparison group:

Although the gamma is a tad dark, it tracks extremely well. Gamma is nearly as important to image quality as contrast, and the PB287Q gives nothing away here.

We calculate gamma deviation by simply expressing the difference from 2.2 as a percentage.

Because of its 2.31 average value, the PB287Q doesn’t look great compared to the rest of the field. Don't let our result deter you though; it's a relatively minor error you can fix on your own by upping the Contrast control (so long as you don’t mind a little less accuracy in the brightest greyscale points). Whether you calibrate or not, we consider the gamma performance to be more than satisfactory.

Ask a Category Expert

Create a new thread in the UK Article comments forum about this subject

Example: Notebook, Android, SSD hard drive

Display all 5 comments.
This thread is closed for comments
  • 0 Hide
    Plusthinking Iq , 27 May 2014 16:05
    too high inputlag for gamers, to bad colors for color work.
    anyone want to buy this must give a shit about work and play.....lol
  • 0 Hide
    13thmonkey , 27 May 2014 19:04
    how does it cope with gaming at 1080p. i.e. what normal people can game at, but might want more windows real estate.
  • 0 Hide
    13thmonkey , 27 May 2014 19:21
    how does it cope with gaming at 1080p. i.e. what normal people can game at, but might want more windows real estate.
  • 0 Hide
    grahmbargh , 28 May 2014 16:11
    Why this push for 4k.... I still hope to see some nice 27-28'' 1440p gaming monitors (or similarly sized 1600p). Is my memory right that some reviews of such products are coming soon?
  • 0 Hide
    jldevoy , 29 May 2014 04:52
    These monitors don't really suit anyone. The people most likely to want 4k res are pros who need better than TN.