Hey there Tech9ne.
Since I don't know that diagnostic tool you've used, would you please post a screenshot of what what you see when you check the whole SMART data. Basically, you should be prompted by the tool if there's anything out of the ordinary. I'd also advise you to check the user manual of the program you're using for more info. You could also post screenshots of what you see about both drives when you test them with the manufacturer's diagnostic tool.
Hope that helps.