Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No

Pirate Bay Faces Ban by European Union

by - source: Tom's Hardware UK

Is The Pirate Bay's galleon under siege by the European Union?

According to TorrentFreak, the European Union may bring the ban hammer down on the infamous Swedish torrent tracker at some point in the near future. The move would be the cornerstone in the governing body's new initiative against media piracy.

The new report has two primary goals. First, it wants to place more liability and responsibility on Internet service providers (ISPs). So, if one ISP sees a consistent amount of piracy-related traffic and does nothing to hinder or cease such traffic, they could be held responsible by the EU. In order to avoid such unpleasantries, the second major goal is for all copyrighted material not being used with permission to be completely filtered out. This is similar to what U.S. organizations like the MPAA and RIAA want on our side of the pond.

To clarify, all of the above is contained in a "tabled non-legislative report", according to the European Parliament's website. So, in layman's terms, it's closer to being "advice" right now than a fully-fledged bill. the report was penned by one Manuel Medina Ortega, who TF pegs as a "Spanish Socialist". Upon further review, Ortega is indeed part of the Socialist Party, as is stated by his official EuroParl bio.

The report makes specific mention of The Pirate Bay, and even urges action against the tracker by individual member nations.According to parts 32 and 33 of a new Motion for a European Parliament Resolution, "32. Approves the action of various national judicial systems against internet sites that illegally disseminate works on line (e.g. ‘The Pirate Bay’); 33. Wishes the activities of such sites to be suspended by the judicial authorities in the Member States." So, while a EU-wide amendment would be preferred, the powers behind the report are pushing for individual countries to take action against torrent trackers.

While we have to wait and see where this report goes, the European Parliament has already made it stance clear. While President Sarkozy of the European Council is in favor of such measures and the "three-strikes" policy, 88% of the European Parliament voted for an amendment that would protect the rights of Internet users in such piracy cases. The "three strikes" policy refers to anti-piracy groups giving ISPs evidence that its users are downloading copyrighted content, which the ISP then uses as grounds to disconnect the user. This sort of partnership infringes on the rights of Internet users, according to the majority of Parliament.

While the MPAA, RIAA, and ISPs like Comcast have anti-piracy/anti-P2P on lockdown in the U.S., any sort of motion in the EU may assist in setting some sort of global precedent. Tom's Hardware will keep you updated on the report and if it finds its way into some sort of full-fledged parliament amendment.

The amended draft report can be found in its entirety here (note: PDF reader required).

Share:
4
Comments
X
Submit

Comments
Add your comment
waxdart 04/02/2009 12:26
Hide
-1+

Illegally disseminate works on line? However, the site is just a list of things. No content being held. Google holds lists of things - It even lists things that are illegal too! The E.U. should ban Google. People can use it to do bad!

AIstudio 04/02/2009 14:11
Hide
-1+

Personally I am absolutely SICK to the back teeth of the RIAA & MPAA.
All they are doing is screwing the honest people, with there DRM etc etc etc.
Do they NEVER learn, pirates will ALWAYS be around, WHY because the big guns charge ridiculous prices!!!
I think the recording industry and others should be brought to justice for selling sub standard material for a high price IE downloads of music (mp3) sub standard and trash compared to a lossles audio track on a cd. They have been creaming everyone for years!!
If they do go down this route piracy will just go down another. Don't forget the Internet hasn't always been around, and pirating was rife before it was.
They just want to control us all like battery hens. Feed us there rubbish and treat us like dirt!!

rant over

Anonymous 04/02/2009 14:38
Hide
-1+

on the same ground the should ban/shut down recording studio or a game producer for failing to deliver entertainment promised to the customer
if a movie puts me to bed after 20 min of watching or a game lands in a dust bin after 2 hrs playing then who's failure is that?
all those greedy people way too long now been favoring quantity over quality & its still not enuf

Humans think 04/02/2009 16:34
Hide
-1+

Speaking as a European citizen, the problem is that MPAA and RIAA beeing American-based don't understand that we have a different culture, and this is the main reason that we don't agree with their biddings. Sharing is a basic element of the European culture, since I was just a kid we used to copy music in tapes and give it as a gift to our friends, we share console games, PC games, software and just about everything else (not our women :P), if a friend asks for a copy of our Office Suite we give it to them instead of saying "Buy you're own you idiot". It's part of the socialist culture I guess...

Internet just made things easier plus consider that most of the software and movies are produced abroad and that the true profits go to the producers and not the artists/programmers (it is known that musicians get most of their money from tours), those facts leave us with no guilts :P

One last thing is that we still consider knowledge a public property, this means that in many European countries the state buys our books, we get free education (schools, universities) and we have organised libraries with free access. So this also applies to subscription based magazines and other stuff, which we try to obtain free. Maybe this is one explanation why an average European has a broader education when compared to an average American (I am not talking of course about "elite" Americans), money is not an prerequisite to get education.

Best offers

Newsletters


OK